7 Best Large and Huge Anal Toys

Why I Chose It

I selected the Oxballs Honcho Size 3 as the Test Winner in this review because you can rarely go wrong with a good quality butt plug. This monstrosity definitely takes the cake as far as huge butt plugs go thanks to the premium quality and amazing performance, according to our tester, Ben. 

Even though he found that the tip was very blunt, “the give that the toy has lends to nearly effortless insertion, and it tapers nicely to the neck once you get past the swell of the thickest point. I like it, and I’ve worn it nearly daily for over a week!”

The only main con I’d like to point out is that the base is slightly smaller than the largest point of the plug. This could mean that it’s at more risk of slipping into you completely. Ben did note that he wished the base was slightly bigger on this size of the Oxballs Honcho. However, he didn’t seem to have any problems with it: 

“I moved around a whole bunch with it in for a whole workday. I even tried to suck the base in to see if I could MAKE it go in. It didn’t budge. […] It is for sure a keeper.”

Luckily, it seems like the lack of taper between the neck of the plug and the base helps keep it in place pretty well.

Why I Chose It

This is my top pick for anyone who’s looking for a huge anal toy for anal stretching and training. Our tester, Devon, found the Oxy Anal Slaughter Huge Butt Plug to be “very comfortable and well made for anal stretching. […] After just three sessions, I am happy with my choice of this plug to be exactly what I need to help me level up.”

Components like the smooth texture, gradually expanding size, and pliability work very well together for pleasurable stretching sessions. What makes it stand out is the comfortable stiffness. Some people experience that silicone toys simply aren’t firm enough for this purpose.

“The Anal Slaughter Huge Butt Plug has the right amount of flexibility to move with my body when thrusting against a solid surface such as the floor, yet enough stiffness to handle most of my body weight without collapsing.”

Now, my main point of critique is that it’s made of PVC, which is a porous material. White Devon notes that it “does not seem like a cheap toy”, he still noticed that “there are some shiny and dull patches” on the surface of the toy. While they didn’t seem alarming to him, it does raise questions about the overall quality. 

Of course, even for anal play, I always tend to recommend using a non-porous material (like silicone, metal, glass, or ABS plastic) since these toys are longer-lasting and easier to keep clean. However, even if you have fallen in love with a PVC toy, like Devon here, just pop a condom on it before use and it’ll be 100% body-safe.

Why I Chose It

The G-Spot Tickler XL Butt Plug is a well-designed huge anal toy for those who love a bit of length as well as girth. The unique curved, slightly asymmetrical design is made to tickle and tease the prostate. According to our tester, Tom, the “unusual shape makes the G-Spot Tickler makes it a winner.”

Since the widest part of the plug is asymmetrical it allows for a nice full feeling stretch, without it feeling too overwhelming. The body itself is also so tapered that it makes insertion easy for even less experienced users.

When taken all the way to the base, the tip is long enough to reach all the way up to the junction of the rectum and the sigmoid colon. For Tom “this is a wonderfully sensitive area, so the sensation was rather enjoyable.”

The only complaint from Tom was that the silicone could have been a tad softer “to more comfortably conform to my rectum”, since he mostly enjoyed using it for wearable depth play.

Why I Chose It

I picked out the SquarePegToys Slink as my top anal snake recommendation because of its high quality material and amazing design. It’s satisfying for experienced users and a great entry-level anal snake as well! 

Our tester, George, loves it! He even notes that he is “currently yet to find any better toy for anal satisfaction. This is my favorite and I often take it with me on holidays.”

The silicone is incredibly flexible, which makes it ideal to use for depth play. It’s relatively easy to navigate the contours of the rectum and colon with something this floppy. George found that “the top is very wiggly and easily slides in, however as soon as you get to the bottom bulb, the struggle begins. It’s a great type of struggle.”

I like that this huge anal toy is quite versatile. First of all, the gradual stretch of the sphincter provided by the cone-like shaft, helps you warm up for other girthy anal toys. Second of all, of course, there’s the depth play which may stimulate areas that most other huge anal toys won’t be able to.

Now, even though I always appreciate when manufacturers offer different sizes and colors of a product, George noted that the large one is still beyond his level of experience, and that “the small is very small and isn’t worth it, even for newbies, the medium is the perfect.”

Why I Chose It

In a review of huge anal toys, you’ve got to have some huge anal beads. That’s where the Cannonballs Giant Silicone Anal Beads come into the picture. According to our tester, Allen, these beads are just as intimidating as they look: 

“These anal beads are MASSIVE, and would be a challenge for even the most experienced anal enthusiasts, but they also make a great goal to strive for, or a project toy.”

Even though they’re made of silicone, they are incredibly firm and have no give whatsoever. Allen found that they acted more like metal toys than silicone ones. While this does make for a great sensation when removed, it makes them very tricky to insert.

“I had to learn how to fist myself just so I could get the Cannonballs in, both of which were no small feat, but should show the difficulty that is involved when using the Cannonballs. Once they were in, they felt great, satisfyingly filling and not uncomfortable in any way.”

Why I Chose It

As far inflatable anal toys go, the Cock Locker Ace of Spades is an impressive construction. This thing is perfect for those who love pushing themselves to their limit (or letting their partner do it for them). 

Our tester, Sierra, was beyond impressed with the size, albeit slightly disappointed that she couldn’t take many pumps before it became overwhelming: 

“I have a toy that is about the width of a soda can but this felt significantly bigger. Another slow squeeze…Oh. Em. Gee. And another – I moaned and whimpered involuntarily (a first for me).”

The Cock Locker Ace of Spades is advertised as having a 15″ circumference but can definitely be inflated well beyond that. Sierra pumped it all the way up to 19” in circumference (6.4” in diameter). So, beware, this plug is BIG. That’s also what makes it amazing for anal girth training.

Overall it’s a pretty decent quality item. Sierra found that the “The latex of the plug feels durable as does the rubber of the hose and the inflation bulb.”

A main drawback is that “there is absolutely no rigidity (in the deflated plug) which makes insertion tricky.” Ideally, it would have a bit more structure!

Why I Chose It

I wanted to include a huge anal toy that offered some vibrations and some less labor-intense pleasures. The B-Vibe Rimming Plug XL may not be the largest toy in this review, but it’s a premium quality vibrating butt plug that still offers an impressive size.

What makes the B-Vibe Rimming Plug XL stand out to me is, obviously, the “rimming” sensations it offers. The rotating beads in the textured neck of the plug are designed to mimic this sensation while sending strong vibrations from the body of the plug as well. Our tester, Tom, wouldn’t equate it to being rimmed, “but it was very nice, nonetheless. It had a gentle, massaging sensation that was very relaxing.”

In terms of design, the taper of the plug made insertion a breeze, and the difference in girth from the wide point to the neck “kept it snugly in place better than most plugs I’ve tried. I found it very comfortable to wear.”

Again, it’s not a huge toy, but it does give a moderate stretch, and a nice massaging sensation. Tom concluded that it was “a nice toy for a relaxing session. It provides sweet, gentle sensations around your anus, and great vibration further in. I think it’s great for foreplay.”