The 13 Best Tail Butt Plugs to Bring Out Your Inner Animal
I’ve searched far and wide to bring you the very best tail butt plugs the world has to offer! I’ve got a whole menagerie including cute bunny tail butt plugs, sexy fox tail plugs, and even mythical, magical unicorn tail butt plugs! I’ve also got furry butt plugs for every budget, plus some amazing animal accessories to complete the look! Today’s test winner is a foxy number from Dominix Deluxe but there are plenty more to choose from too!
Test Winner | Cheapest | Beginner | Set | Extra Long | Glass | Posable | Unicorn | Rainbow | Puppy | Remote control | Wolf | Pony | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
DOMINIX Steel Fox Tail Butt Plug | Blush Temptasia Bunny Tail Plug | Silicone Bunny Butt Plug | Tailz Snap-On Interchangeable Tails Set | Tailz Aluminum Plug With Mink Tail | DOMINIX Animal Tail Butt Plug | Happy Rabbit Bunny Tail Butt Plug | Tailz Bad Kitty Anal Plug W/ Black Cat Tail | Unicorn Plug Set | Pride Foxtail Butt Plug | Tailz Puppy Play Set | Tailz Waggerz Anal Plug With Tail & Remote | Tailz Black Grey Wolf Plug | My Lil Pony Tail |
Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price | Check price |
Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons | Pros & Cons |
Table of contents (19)
How We Test tail butt plugs
We’re a team of 262 sex toy testers and 13 sex toy experts.
To find the very best tail butt plugs, our testers tried and reviewed 80 different products in this category.
Bad or even just mediocre tail butt plugs didn’t make the list!
In total, we’ve thoroughly tested and reviewed 721 toys over the past 6 years.
We even lab-tested some to get objective data.
Read more about how we test products.How to Choose Your Ideal Tail Butt Plug
It might be tempting to click “Buy Now” on the first cute plug you see but you should actually put some thought into your next furry tail butt plug! Below, we’ve written a short list of factors for you to consider (as well as why they actually matter!) while searching for your new favorite plug.
- Plug Size – There are many different sizes of butt plugs available, so you shouldn’t have any trouble finding the right size. If you’re new to anal play then we’d recommend starting with more conservative options (you can always work your way up to larger toys!).
- Plug Shape – The shape of the plug will affect two things: how easy the toy is to insert & how it feels during insertion/removal. Plugs with taped tips are the easiest to insert, and those with a longer taper will be even easier. While many plugs are smooth, some companies do offer ribbed plugs that provide added stimulation during insertion/removal.
- Material – Silicone is the best soft plug material. However, glass and metal are also great options if you enjoy temperature play. All three of these materials are non-porous, meaning the plug can be sterilized after use. You’ll also want to consider the material used to make the tail. While some toys do use real animal fur, most utilize faux fur instead.
- Vibration – Although optional, many people find that using an anal vibrator is more satisfying than a simple butt plug. If you do decide to go with a vibrating toy, we’d recommend making sure that it offers enough functions (speeds & patterns) to make it worth spending the extra money for the feature.
- Ease of Cleaning – All plugs can be cleaned using antibacterial soap and warm water. Non-porous materials can be sterilized, but if your tail butt plug contains electronic components then you won’t be able to sterilize it using boiling water. Plugs with removable tails will be the easiest to clean, although it’s not too hard to clean a plug with a non-removable tail either.
- Price – Obviously, a vibrating butt plug is going to cost more than a plain plug. Still, prices can vary quite a bit, which means you can usually find a great deal no matter what type of plug you’re after. It’s a good idea to compare prices from multiple websites if you want to get the best deals.
Test Winner DOMINIX Deluxe Stainless Steel Faux Fox Tail Butt Plug
If you want to feel a bit “foxy” then buying this fox tail butt plug should be a no-brainer! The long and fluffy tail is sure to tickle and tease your partner as you rub against them, perfect for any fox-based fantasies you two might indulge in.
Whereas some plugs are so light that you can barely tell they’re inside you, this DOMINIX tail butt plug weighs 6.7 ounces so you’re sure to notice the stimulating sensations in your rear! The added weight is sure to enhance orgasms, whether you’re having sex with your partner or using a vibrator on yourself.
Since the plug is made out of water-safe metal you can easily heat or cool this toy to your desired temperature before insertion, adding another level of fun to this foxy tail plug!
Pros
- ✅ Heavy plug weight
- ✅ Perfect for solo & partner play
- ✅ Comes in a satin bag
- ✅ Can be gently tugged upon
Cons
- ❌ Minimal insertable length
- ❌ Not adjustable
- ❌ Small plug size
- ❌ Not as fluffy as photos imply
Why I Chose It
This is one of the best tail butt plugs for a very reasonable price, which is why I chose this as today’s test winner! The tail looks realistic enough for nearly any foxy encounters you might be planning, and the toy can even take some light tugging for added sensations.
This is definitely a high-quality tail plug overall, although (as some users have noted) the actual tail isn’t quite as poofy as implied in the photos.
The tail is especially good for teasing your partner since the tail is long enough to cover the “goods”, driving your partner wild before they brush it aside. The tail uses a screw-on design so it can be removed for easier cleaning, but some people have struggled doing this. For an easier time, we’d recommend wiping off the plug to reduce lubrication before attempting to remove the tail from the toy.
Show coupon
15% coupon available
Cheapest Blush Temptasia Bunny Tail Pom Butt Plug
If you love a bargain, think bunnies are cute, and want a simple way to spice up your partner (or solo) play, then you might want to check out this bunny tail butt plug from Blush Tempasia!
Designed to look like the puffy tail of a little black rabbit, this toy is perfect for all-day use thanks to the soft fur & t-base design. The tail can also be removed for easy cleaning or plug-only use.
If you want a way to look cute and enjoy some anal stimulation throughout your play then this tail butt plug might be just the thing for you!
Pros
- ✅ Cruelty-free
- ✅ Removable tail
- ✅ T-base design
- ✅ Easy to clean
Cons
- ❌ One color only
- ❌ Short insertable length
- ❌ Too short to pull easily
Why I Chose It
Since it’s based on a rabbit’s tail this tail butt plug is relatively short and poofy compared to other tail plugs. The downside of that is you won’t be able to grab and lightly pull on it very easily, but the upside is that you can wear this toy discreetly throughout your day with much fuss!
If you love wearing a tail butt plug around the house as you clean but are worried about your tail getting caught, this poofy tail is a good option. The t-base design ensures day-long comfort, and the cute tail is sure to make your partner take a second glance at your derriere!
Show coupon
5% coupon available
Beginner Playful Silicone Small Bunny Tail Butt Plug
If you’ve never tried butt play before then a butt plug is probably a great place to start! Of course, there are many options out there, so if you want something besides a plain-looking plug then this pink bunny tail butt plug might be worth checking out!
At just under $20, this beginner-friendly toy is fairly priced, easy to use, and perfect as an introduction to pet play. Unlike some other models, the tail on this toy isn’t removable, which prevents you from losing your tail while “in the moment”!
Some users have even worn this plug all day, although we would probably recommend a t-bar base butt plug instead for that. Still, you can’t deny that this toy is both comfortable & stimulating as it sits nestled between both cheeks, so why not give it a shot? You definitely won’t regret it!
Pros
- ✅ Tapered tip
- ✅ Latex and Phthalate-Free
- ✅ Beginner-friendly girth
- ✅ Easy to insert
Cons
Reviewed by:
Kevin Foley